Wireless products come in
many different "flavors" and differences between some of them
are subtle.
Let's start by looking at the different types of "Client
Adapters".
These products are used to connect one
device to a wireless network, much like an Ethernet network interface
card (NIC). Most of the adapters can work either in a peer-to-peer
network (this is called Ad Hoc mode), or through an Access Point that
connects to a larger, usually wired, network (Infrastructure mode).
HomeRF based devices also support both methods of communication, but
switch methods on the fly.
PC Card
This format is familiar to laptop and PDA users and comes in 16bit
and CardBus (32 bit) forms. Unfortunately, manufacturers often don't
tell you which technology they use, so if your laptop supports only
CardBus adapters, you may have do experiment to find out whether a
product will work for you. PC Cards have been the format of choice for
laptop users, but have the disadvantages of relatively high power usage
and poor antenna orientation.
USB
Our method of choice for connecting desktop machines. These adapters
have the advantages of no-opening-the-box installation and a cable
connection that allows positioning the adapter's antenna for optimum
signal. The biggest negative is that you may experience the same driver
related problems that plague other USB devices.
Unless you have many active USB devices
attached to your computer, you don't need to worry about USB's speed
limitation, since most 802.11b adapters' maximum throughput is about
5Mbps compared to the 8Mbps or so that you'll get from most USB host
adapters.
PCI and ISA
Given the other choices available, these internal card format
devices are quickly fading away. Most manufacturers sell you a separate
PCI adapter to use with their standard PC Card wireless adapter, and
you'll have to hunt to find companies who also offer an ISA bus adapter.
Built-In
There are not many nice things that we can say about this method. It's
more costly, installations tend to difficult, and the resulting antenna
orientation (sticking horizontally out the rear, low to the floor, and
pointing toward an outside wall) is usually terrible for performance! If
you do choose this method, buy your adapter from the same company as
your PC card radio. No manufacturer will support the use of another's
radio card in their adapter.
This option is becoming almost standard
in current-generation notebook computers and PDAs. The main advantage of
building a wireless adapter into a notebook is that the antenna is
generally also integrated -- usually into the notebook's screen. This
puts the antenna(s) into a vertical polarization, matching the
polarization of most Access Points, and therefore improving the
notebook's range. The built-in adapter is also more robust, since it
doesn't stick out of the side of the notebook, begging to be broken off.
The main disadvantages are that this
option is usually the most expensive one, and that you are limited to
the one adapter that your notebook's manufacturer selects. If you go
this route, also check to see how difficult it is to power down the
wireless connection. You'll definitely want to do that when you don't
need it, since an 802.11b radio can easily cut your notebook's battery
life in half, even if you are not actively using the card.
Product
Types - Access Points (AP) and Bridges
Access Points
In its generic form, an Access Point is a wireless transceiver that
connects a wired LAN with wireless clients. An AP makes this
connection in a way that makes the wired and wireless clients appear to
be in the same network.
NOTE: An AP in its basic
form can only connect to wireless clients, and not to another
AP.
This category of devices can get
confusing, given the way that some manufacturers have named their
products and enhanced their feature sets to include "bridging"
features. See the next section for more info.
Bridges
The generic networking term "Bridge" refers to a device
that connects two LANs. Therefore, when you want to connect two (or
more) LANs via a wireless connection, use wireless bridges.
But beware! This product category is
probably the most confusing, and holds the most potential for a customer
to choose a product that doesn't really do what they require. For
example, a number of manufacturers have added bridging features to their
Access Points and not renamed their products (Linksys WAP11), or called
their products bridges when they also support Access Point functions (SMC
2682W). There are also "bridge" products that support
only one attached device. Our only advice here is to read the product
feature description very carefully and don't rely on the name of a
product to tell you what it does.
Once you select a product, you'll have to
configure it. There are a number of wireless bridging modes, and of
course, manufacturers have not used the same terminology. Let's see if
we can untangle things a bit:
-
Point-to-Point - The simplest
bridging mode where one bridge unit talks to another. You usually
enter the MAC address of the unit on the other end of the connection
in each bridge's configuration screen. Manufacturers are pretty
consistent in describing this mode and the way it's set up.
-
Point-to-Multipoint - This
mode allows multiple networks to be connected. The modes used in the
setup vary from manufacturer to manufacturer. SMC's 2682W, for
example, requires one unit to be set as a "Bridge Master",
and the other bridge units to be set as "Bridge Slaves".
Linksys' WAP11 has you set one unit to Point-to-Multipoint, and the
others to Point-to-Point mode, with the "Remote MAC
address" set to the MAC address of the box set to
Point-to-Multipoint mode. Confused? Wait, there's more...
-
AP plus Bridging (AP Client) -
Manufacturers try to confuse you on this feature, but in theory,
it's simple. It's basically a mode that sets a bridge to work with
an Access Point, instead of another bridge. Manufacturers are fuzzy
on the details of how this works, but one result is to create a
wireless Client Adapter that has an Ethernet output. Another
possibility is to create a network where your "local" AP
supports wireless clients and wirelessly connects to an Ethernet
based LAN, i.e., more than one Ethernet client. In this mode,
however, the "remote" end of the connection can't talk to
wireless clients. To do that you need to find a product that
supports the next mode...
-
Wireless Repeater - Access
Points normally require an Ethernet connection when multiple units
are used to extend the range of a wireless LAN. Wireless repeating
eliminates the need for the Ethernet cable, and allows multiple APs
to both connect to wireless clients and to other APs that support
wireless repeating. This is a very nice feature to have, but you'll
pay for it, since it's typically only available on products priced
above $500. A cheaper way to go is actually to connect two of the
less expensive AP/Bridges together.
As if all the above weren't confusing
enough, there are also products that allow devices that have only an
Ethernet or serial connection to be added to your wireless network. 3Com
calls theirs an Ethernet
Client Bridge, while Linksys' product goes by the "Wireless
to Ethernet Adapter" moniker (Linksys WET11). Client Adapter or
Bridge? You decide!
Product
Types - Wireless Routers
After all the confusion in the Access
Point / Bridge category, you'll find Wireless Routers easy to
understand! Wireless routers combine the connection sharing features of
a router with those of a wireless Access Point. Most products take a
basic router, steal one of the LAN Ethernet ports, and internally
connect it to a radio module. They then add AP functions to the router's
firmware.
The main difference between a wireless
Router and Access Point is that an Access Point doesn't provide firewall
or Internet connection sharing and a Wireless Router does.
NOTE: It's possible to use
a wireless router as an Access Point. Just disable the router's DHCP
server and use only the LAN ports to connect your Ethernet devices.
|